"Like awarding one little league team five outs per inning and six strikes per batter, then doing a victory dance because they have a good inning, President Obama applauded the "success" of his GM bailout in a visit to Detroit last week."A perfect analogy, and a very good column.
Wednesday, August 4, 2010
Quote of the Week - August 4th
I've been thinking about posting something about the Obama Administration's public high-fives over a single profitable quarter for GM for a while now, but Holman W. Jenkins, Jr. sums it up perfectly with the following quote leading off his column today:
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
Dangers of an Inexperienced Executive
The Shirley Sherrod story is a perfect case study for why governments full of career politicians and devoid of any real world executive experience are ineffective and downright dangerous.
In a world that revolves around 24/7 “news” coverage, re-election campaigns, approval ratings, the results of the latest Gallop polls and other self-serving political maneuverings, the things that executives should be focused on – little things like sticking to a budget, maintaining employee engagement and motivation, making a payroll, staying solvent, etc. - tend to take a back seat to pure politics.
Imagine being summoned to your boss’s office where he shows you a 20 second YouTube clip, edited by some random guy, of your recent speech at an industry forum. The content of that 20 second clip, when watched in a vacuum, is admittedly very controversial and is in direct conflict with your current job description. However, you know that the speech evolves to demonstrate that the ideas expressed in that 20-second clip are in fact inappropriate, and the speech, when taken as a whole, is actually very powerful and inspirational.
When the clip ends, your boss fires you. Pack up and leave the building immediately. We’re not interested in your side of the story. Bu-Bye.
Before you’ve left your boss’s office, the CEO of your Company has issued a public statement through his press secretary condemning your views and assuring its shareholders that your views don’t represent the views of the Company.
For about 5 minutes, Company executives walk around with chests puffed out feeling great about how they found a problem and dealt with it swiftly before its critics could take the story too far. The three random bloggers who also saw and condemned the clip can no longer rage on about it. Wow, what a relief.
5 minutes after that, HR starts their due diligence around the firing and the very first thing they do is find the entire speech. Uh-Oh. HR sends the full speech around and everyone who reads it is horrified to find out that the grainy YouTube clip was in fact edited in such a way that it totally misrepresents the actual message in the speech. Therefore, a hard-working and loyal employee was just sent out to pasture because the Company was too caught up in its own politic to take 30 minutes out of its day and perform some due diligence on the clip. 5 minutes of searching and 20 minutes of listening/reading the speech and it would have been clear as day that the 20 second YouTube clip was not representative of the speech as a whole. The employee should have been commended for such a speech, not fired.
Before you’ve finished packing up your desk, you boss comes running back to you apologizing and begging you to stay. Your CEO’s press secretary has now issued another public statement apologizing for their haste.
What’s the message in all of this?
You and all of your colleagues now realize that the Company would gladly throw its employees under the bus to avoid any type of political crisis, real or fictional. How much confidence would you have in your CEO if this happened at your Company?
It’s a rhetorical question, this would never happen at your Company because its run by an experienced executive who actually requests all the facts before making any decisions, especially a decision to publically trash the character of a hard-working and successful employee based solely on an edited 20-second clip posted on YouTube.
Unfortunately, as we all now know, the Shirley Sherrod story is a very real life example of this shameful behavior starring the United States Department of Agriculture as the Company, Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack as the boss and President Obama as the CEO.
The lack of real life executive experience within the White House continues to rear its ugly head. The White House’s incredibly amateurish and politicized treatment of the Shirley Sherrod events is a crystal clear example of the dangers of having inexperienced executives in and around the Oval Office.
In a world that revolves around 24/7 “news” coverage, re-election campaigns, approval ratings, the results of the latest Gallop polls and other self-serving political maneuverings, the things that executives should be focused on – little things like sticking to a budget, maintaining employee engagement and motivation, making a payroll, staying solvent, etc. - tend to take a back seat to pure politics.
Imagine being summoned to your boss’s office where he shows you a 20 second YouTube clip, edited by some random guy, of your recent speech at an industry forum. The content of that 20 second clip, when watched in a vacuum, is admittedly very controversial and is in direct conflict with your current job description. However, you know that the speech evolves to demonstrate that the ideas expressed in that 20-second clip are in fact inappropriate, and the speech, when taken as a whole, is actually very powerful and inspirational.
When the clip ends, your boss fires you. Pack up and leave the building immediately. We’re not interested in your side of the story. Bu-Bye.
Before you’ve left your boss’s office, the CEO of your Company has issued a public statement through his press secretary condemning your views and assuring its shareholders that your views don’t represent the views of the Company.
For about 5 minutes, Company executives walk around with chests puffed out feeling great about how they found a problem and dealt with it swiftly before its critics could take the story too far. The three random bloggers who also saw and condemned the clip can no longer rage on about it. Wow, what a relief.
5 minutes after that, HR starts their due diligence around the firing and the very first thing they do is find the entire speech. Uh-Oh. HR sends the full speech around and everyone who reads it is horrified to find out that the grainy YouTube clip was in fact edited in such a way that it totally misrepresents the actual message in the speech. Therefore, a hard-working and loyal employee was just sent out to pasture because the Company was too caught up in its own politic to take 30 minutes out of its day and perform some due diligence on the clip. 5 minutes of searching and 20 minutes of listening/reading the speech and it would have been clear as day that the 20 second YouTube clip was not representative of the speech as a whole. The employee should have been commended for such a speech, not fired.
Before you’ve finished packing up your desk, you boss comes running back to you apologizing and begging you to stay. Your CEO’s press secretary has now issued another public statement apologizing for their haste.
What’s the message in all of this?
You and all of your colleagues now realize that the Company would gladly throw its employees under the bus to avoid any type of political crisis, real or fictional. How much confidence would you have in your CEO if this happened at your Company?
It’s a rhetorical question, this would never happen at your Company because its run by an experienced executive who actually requests all the facts before making any decisions, especially a decision to publically trash the character of a hard-working and successful employee based solely on an edited 20-second clip posted on YouTube.
Unfortunately, as we all now know, the Shirley Sherrod story is a very real life example of this shameful behavior starring the United States Department of Agriculture as the Company, Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack as the boss and President Obama as the CEO.
The lack of real life executive experience within the White House continues to rear its ugly head. The White House’s incredibly amateurish and politicized treatment of the Shirley Sherrod events is a crystal clear example of the dangers of having inexperienced executives in and around the Oval Office.
Wednesday, May 19, 2010
Reforming the Symptom, Ignoring the Disease
“Reform” seems to have taken over from “Change” as the new buzzword in Washington these days.
For a variety of reasons, but primarily because of the political toxicity of addressing our root problems, Congress and the Administration have decided to put band-aids labelled as “reform” over the populist-defined “problems” facing our country today.
However, it’s clear that these “problems” are nothing more than symptoms of larger, more fundamental disease that Congress refuses to acknowledge.
We all know what happens when you treat a symptom and not the underlying cause. The pain might subside for a while, but it always comes back with a vengeance, causing even more damage and suffering.
Let’s use “Financial Reform” as an example. In the never-ending search for a politically convenient scapegoat for which to pin the blame of the “Great Recession”, the popular targets are the big bad banks on Wall Street and their influence on our entire financial system. This includes misguided angst regarding topics such as derivatives and proprietary trading activities, and an incredible lack of angst or urgency for any “reforms” for Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae. These are two government run entities that lost a combined $19.8 billion of taxpayer money in just the first quarter of 2010 - that’s $220 million dollars A DAY! This lack of focus on Freddie and Fannie, while unforgivable, is not the least bit surprising given that Congressional fingerprints are all over that crime scene. Better to sweep them under the rug until the next round of elections is over.
Not that long ago, Congress wasn’t so confident on the causes of the “Great Recession” and the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission was set up to shed some light on exactly what happened. However, before this Committee has issued a single word in recommendations or conclusions, Congress is taking it upon itself to make its own determinations and “reform” the financial system accordingly.
Would you start chemotherapy without a doctor telling you that you have cancer? Would you start a controversial, radical and experimental drug therapy with crippling side-effects, without a doctor telling you what ailment you’re trying to cure?
Allow me to indulge myself for a minute and pretend to be a Doctor and Mr. Economy just walked through my office door. I can tell right away that there is a problem. I ask him what his symptoms are and he responds as follows:
• Unemployment is high
• House prices are down
• Consumer spending has crashed to the floor, taking corporate profits along for the ride.
• People and companies are defaulting on their loans left, right and center
He goes on and on citing symptom after symptom.
My job as his Doctor would be to determine whether these are all isolated problems that require specific treatments or if these are just symptoms of a more fundamental problem. It doesn’t take a Nobel Prize winner to see that the above are just symptoms of a fundamental problem.
To clear up the symptoms, the fundamental problem needs to be identified and treated. Fire fighting each individual symptom with separate treatments (e.g. tax credits for hiring employees, artificial propping up of the housing market through tax credits and loan modification programs, stimulus programs to increase spending, Financial “reform”, etc.) is not only a very expensive and time consuming exercise, but it may also just mask the root problem for a period of time before it hits back even harder in the future.
Looking at the symptoms, some are clearly direct results of others – but when you wade through all the populist rhetoric, what is really at the root of these symptoms?
Isn’t that a question for the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission? Wouldn’t it make sense to wait until they have completed their assessments (due by Dec 2010) before we run off and “reform” everything in sight for the sake of “reform”?
In my not-so-expert opinion, the root cause of this crisis trickles down to every American who couldn’t keep their financial house in order. Whether it was taking out an aggressive mortgage, racking up too much credit card debt, or just simply not living within their means - personal financial responsibility was in shambles and when the music stopped the entire system can crashing down, bringing everyone along for the ride. It makes us feel better to blame our mortgage broker, our bank, our credit card company, the "rich", the "poor" - anyone other than ouselves.
If individuals were the drivers behind the “Great Recession” roller coaster, Government policies laid down the tracks used to permit, promote and in some cases even excuse this lack of responsibility. Every aspect of the financial landscape was impacted by some Government policy or subsidy that encouraged this behaviour. The clearest example is in the housing market where low interest rates, mortgage interest tax deductions and Congressional mandates that more low income (i.e. sub-prime) families should be homeowners (via Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, see above), all contributed to the expansion of what we now know was a property bubbles of epic proportions. In fact, one could argue that Government policies (tax credits for buying a house, loan modification programs, debt forgiveness, etc.) are still artificially propping up the property market.
While it would be convenient to place the blame on Government’s insatiable appetite for self-promotion and re-election, best achieved by providing voters with something for nothing, I still believe the ultimate blame should fall to each and every American who lived outside of their financial means. Regardless of how easy the Government made it to over extend our personal finances, the ultimate responsibility lands with the individual, and until we realize this and change our behaviour accordingly, I don’t expect the “reform” band-aids to prevent Mr. Economy from making repeat visits into my Doctors office complaining of the same old symptoms, over and over again.
For a variety of reasons, but primarily because of the political toxicity of addressing our root problems, Congress and the Administration have decided to put band-aids labelled as “reform” over the populist-defined “problems” facing our country today.
However, it’s clear that these “problems” are nothing more than symptoms of larger, more fundamental disease that Congress refuses to acknowledge.
We all know what happens when you treat a symptom and not the underlying cause. The pain might subside for a while, but it always comes back with a vengeance, causing even more damage and suffering.
Let’s use “Financial Reform” as an example. In the never-ending search for a politically convenient scapegoat for which to pin the blame of the “Great Recession”, the popular targets are the big bad banks on Wall Street and their influence on our entire financial system. This includes misguided angst regarding topics such as derivatives and proprietary trading activities, and an incredible lack of angst or urgency for any “reforms” for Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae. These are two government run entities that lost a combined $19.8 billion of taxpayer money in just the first quarter of 2010 - that’s $220 million dollars A DAY! This lack of focus on Freddie and Fannie, while unforgivable, is not the least bit surprising given that Congressional fingerprints are all over that crime scene. Better to sweep them under the rug until the next round of elections is over.
Not that long ago, Congress wasn’t so confident on the causes of the “Great Recession” and the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission was set up to shed some light on exactly what happened. However, before this Committee has issued a single word in recommendations or conclusions, Congress is taking it upon itself to make its own determinations and “reform” the financial system accordingly.
Would you start chemotherapy without a doctor telling you that you have cancer? Would you start a controversial, radical and experimental drug therapy with crippling side-effects, without a doctor telling you what ailment you’re trying to cure?
Allow me to indulge myself for a minute and pretend to be a Doctor and Mr. Economy just walked through my office door. I can tell right away that there is a problem. I ask him what his symptoms are and he responds as follows:
• Unemployment is high
• House prices are down
• Consumer spending has crashed to the floor, taking corporate profits along for the ride.
• People and companies are defaulting on their loans left, right and center
He goes on and on citing symptom after symptom.
My job as his Doctor would be to determine whether these are all isolated problems that require specific treatments or if these are just symptoms of a more fundamental problem. It doesn’t take a Nobel Prize winner to see that the above are just symptoms of a fundamental problem.
To clear up the symptoms, the fundamental problem needs to be identified and treated. Fire fighting each individual symptom with separate treatments (e.g. tax credits for hiring employees, artificial propping up of the housing market through tax credits and loan modification programs, stimulus programs to increase spending, Financial “reform”, etc.) is not only a very expensive and time consuming exercise, but it may also just mask the root problem for a period of time before it hits back even harder in the future.
Looking at the symptoms, some are clearly direct results of others – but when you wade through all the populist rhetoric, what is really at the root of these symptoms?
Isn’t that a question for the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission? Wouldn’t it make sense to wait until they have completed their assessments (due by Dec 2010) before we run off and “reform” everything in sight for the sake of “reform”?
In my not-so-expert opinion, the root cause of this crisis trickles down to every American who couldn’t keep their financial house in order. Whether it was taking out an aggressive mortgage, racking up too much credit card debt, or just simply not living within their means - personal financial responsibility was in shambles and when the music stopped the entire system can crashing down, bringing everyone along for the ride. It makes us feel better to blame our mortgage broker, our bank, our credit card company, the "rich", the "poor" - anyone other than ouselves.
If individuals were the drivers behind the “Great Recession” roller coaster, Government policies laid down the tracks used to permit, promote and in some cases even excuse this lack of responsibility. Every aspect of the financial landscape was impacted by some Government policy or subsidy that encouraged this behaviour. The clearest example is in the housing market where low interest rates, mortgage interest tax deductions and Congressional mandates that more low income (i.e. sub-prime) families should be homeowners (via Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, see above), all contributed to the expansion of what we now know was a property bubbles of epic proportions. In fact, one could argue that Government policies (tax credits for buying a house, loan modification programs, debt forgiveness, etc.) are still artificially propping up the property market.
While it would be convenient to place the blame on Government’s insatiable appetite for self-promotion and re-election, best achieved by providing voters with something for nothing, I still believe the ultimate blame should fall to each and every American who lived outside of their financial means. Regardless of how easy the Government made it to over extend our personal finances, the ultimate responsibility lands with the individual, and until we realize this and change our behaviour accordingly, I don’t expect the “reform” band-aids to prevent Mr. Economy from making repeat visits into my Doctors office complaining of the same old symptoms, over and over again.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)